Madonna in a Fur Coat by Sabahattin Ali is an exploration of a doomed relationship as seen through the eyes of a young, recluse, despondent man. It shows the complexities of love and longing, yearning, the fleeting nature of happiness and the emotional toll of unrequited love.
Poetically written, this 1920s-set novel explores the inner workings of the protagonist Raif Efendi’s mind. It follows his infatuation with a self-portrait painting (the “Madonna in a Fur Coat) following his move from Turkey to Berlin, and later with its artist Maria Puder. His obsession with Maria grows, forming an unconventional love story of rejection and self-worth. Through Raif’s falling for Maria, he finds a purpose for living and overall meaning in his days, which he had never experienced before. The theme of unrequited love follows Raif throughout the novel, shaping his lived experience, as his sense of self and outlook on life fluctuate depending on where he believes he stands with Maria.
While the novel is praised for its emotional depth and introspective nature, it is deeply imbalanced, and this imbalance reveals one of the novel’s key flaws. Although Maria is presented as a bold, independent, and self-assured woman who rejects traditional roles in relationships, her presence is entirely filtered through Raif’s perception, leaving her inner world and motivations unexplored. She ultimately becomes more of a symbol of purpose and meaning in Raif’s life rather than a fully realised partner in the relationship overall. This one-sidedness contributes to the novel’s portrayal of unrequited love and longing, as Raif projects his hopes, ideals, and need for meaning onto Maria, making the relationship feel less like a mutual love story and more like a quiet obsession. The love story, while poetic and affecting, can thus feel less like a dialogue between equals and more like an echo chamber of Raif’s inner world.
This narrative imbalance might be read as intentional and stand as a reflection of how people often fall in love with an idea of someone rather than who they truly are. Still, it also limits the emotional complexity of the novel, as Maria’s character becomes trapped in the very idealisation she once resisted.
Overall, Madonna in a Fur Coat is a hauntingly beautiful yet somewhat emotionally lopsided story that captures the ache of yearning and quiet tragedy of loving another, or merely the idea of another, more than yourself. This novel left me moved, but ultimately questioning whose story is being told.
Rating: 4/5
Purchase Madonna in a Fur Coat by Sabahattin Ali here.
Read more of our Book Reviews here.
